I recently had lunch with a good friend, a Korean-American husband and dad with an impressive career in the federal government. Again, send your questions to ezrakleinshow@nytimes.com with A.M.A. in the subject line. So for instance, when DeSantis defends some of his culture war-style bills about education in Florida, DeSantis will obscure his own role and agency in them. And I just dont know. I think one of the reasons he got a lot of attention is he ran up the score larger than the polls suggested. I wonder now listening to that if some of this is geographic, because I just, in California, always heard much more about Texas. So one about Covid and how he remade himself around that. And I am declaring very early that I think DeSantis is a special figure in the Republican Party right now. by | Oct 29, 2021 | 415 417 south 10th street philadelphia, pa | is black tip ammo legal | Oct 29, 2021 | 415 417 south 10th street philadelphia, pa | is black tip ammo legal Michael Brendan Dougherty And its falling between two different versions of itself, whereas Democrats are still held together, partly out of total fear of Donald Trump. One answer is she exulted in being an unmarried mother. And heres our email: letters@nytimes.com. It inspires weightless ditties like Gather Us In. Lets sing about us! Very chic and intellectual, you know! Michael Brendan Dougherty's My Father Left Me Ireland Margot Metroland 2,318 words. Theres Been a Revolution in How China Is Governed, How Right-Wing Media Ate the Republican Party, A Revelatory Tour of Martin Luther King Jr.s Forgotten Teachings, A Conservatives Take on the Chaotic State of the Republican Party, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/02/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-michael-brendan-dougherty.html. As a college athlete, Penders played both basketball and baseball for the University of Connecticut, and is one of the few players to have competed in both the NCAA tournament as well as the College World Series. Paul Krugman Breaks It Down. Its terrifying at times and I know that Globohomos modus operandi is to leave you alone, apathetic, and terrified. And yet, hes going to improve the partys share among Hispanics over the lifetime of his presidency in a way that would have been totally unthinkable in 2012. Lets say I buy your take on DeSantis and Covid. But thats because the magic is me. [The] event will open with a panel discussion moderated by Fordham University Political Science Assistant Professor Christina Greer with political analysis from Michael Brendan Dougherty (The . And I think it appeals to people who are immune to C.S. But there is a thread running through these beads, and it is the authors spiritual development, which culminates in the discovery of his own vocation as a father. His digressive letters let him hop all over the map, going on about Irish history, and the misconceptions that the Irish in Ireland have about themselves. Given the violence that nationalism often generates, why not also distinguish between national culture and the nation-state? One of these assumptions was about the value of patriotism. But Democrats are a complex coalition, too. You can listen to our whole conversation by following The Ezra Klein Show on Apple, Spotify, Google or wherever you get your podcasts. It reminds me of something that journalist Molly Ball said about Trump in 2016, which I always thought was very smart, where she said, all the other candidates that get up on the stage and Im paraphrasing her here, of course and they say voters are angry, and I understand that. And now youre seeing, partly, I think the success of that in Florida, which experienced the red tsunami that landed nowhere else. Were never told, but it appears she was some kind of high-level administrative assistant. (See my discussion of the movie and the book. argo parts amazon. They have a disastrous midterm in 2018. And the fact that there was a lot surprised me. It seemed risqu and bohemian. . We discussed fatherhood, particularly the central role fathers play in imparting identity to their children. And what was so funny was on Fox News, they didnt even show the whole speech live. And the truth is that, in 2023, Republicans are going to hold an enormous amount of power. As Jonathan Bowden said, there is always a socialist element to racialism, a What are the to-go-sites of the Incel community? I didnt think she translated from South Carolina to the national stage perfectly well. The Mass-goers there werent exactly a community; we were a clandestine network of romantics, haters of Pope John Paul II, people who had been jilted by the mainstream church and I believe some saints. The American Ideas Institute is a nonprofit, non-partisan 501(c)(3) organization based in Washington, D.C. 2022 The American Conservative, a publication of The American Ideas Institute. And then he goes back to the gated community and maybe holds a fundraiser in the gated community and then tries to get to work. This is mini-Trump. [LAUGHS]. [LAUGHS]. AEI scholars, fellows, and their guests frequently take positions on policy and other issues. I would argue that as well. The prayers of the traditional Mass emphasized that the priest was re-presenting the same sacrifice Christ made at Calvary, one that propitiated Gods wrath at sin and reconciled humanity to God. For all the legitimate decent dissenting voices like Keith Woods, Grand our national news service is basically Paddy Pravda. Weve never met these people. But its the sort of thing that I think actually worked for him politically, is that Im going to highlight to you how much I care about an issue that isnt being talked about by saying the most outrageous thing imaginable about it. "Who were you, anyway?" Dougherty asks his father. demonstration. Probably pushed some Democrats off the registered rolls. And I think the thing that really has driven DeSantis to the top of alternatives to Donald Trump in the Republican Party is that he is identifiably bringing people into the Republican Party. The question arises why someone as intelligent and presentable as she did not at leastpretendto be a widow or find a real husband. And when I looked at it at that time, he didnt look very different to me than Texas, didnt look very different to me than Georgia, didnt look very different to me, actually, than a lot of the Southwest, which took this approach. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. The ferocity of his campaign will push these young families and communities toward the radicalism I imbibed years ago in Poughkeepsie, before Benedict. I was struck by how similar Doughertys experience is to that of a Latin American living in the United Statesnot only my own experience, but also that of friends from other places south of the border. And theres a kind of argument thats about broad positioning that a lot of different kind of candidates could fit into. It is not the coherent representative of one particular class or class interest, although those are implicated in it. And he doesnt have buildings with his name on them all over the country and golf courses all over the world. The same can be said for Dougherty, who does not live in Ireland. All they want to do is win. And theres another reason for that obscurity or that seeming obscurity in your part, which is that Floridas Republican legislature and governors have actually removed, from the political discussion, lots of policy options on taxes and spending that would potentially give you clues. Theres Democrats after 04 and heartland voters. Michael Brendan Dougherty, a senior writer at National Review and a visiting fellow for the social, cultural and constitutional studies division at the American Enterprise Institute, is the author of My Father Left Me Ireland: An American Sons Search for Home.. The immigration folks in South Croydon looked for things like that. How is that being processed? And him winning certain counties in Florida, like Miami-Dade or Osceola, that are typically out of reach for Republicans. Its hard to identify any clear party leader, coherent policy agenda or concerted electoral strategy. The new ritual points us toward a bare table, and it consistently posits the unity of humankind as the ultimate horizon of our existence. He may have grown up in the ugly anonymous suburbs of New York, but it is to such communities, however imperfect, that he owes his first and unparalleled allegiance. So thats one narrative. Think of Mozarts great rendition of faith in the Eucharist: Ave Verum Corpus (Hail True Body). Clearly, Dougherty is no STEM faddist. Americans have remained remarkably immune to this poison of ahistoricity, perhaps because were so steeped in lore factual, fictional, and filmic particularly about the Old South and the settlement of the West, not to mention the horrors of Indian fighting. If you have Paywall access,
Its ultimately in the same genre as the Vance book, but succeeds better in its ultimate aim. Michael Brendan Dougherty is a senior writer at the National Review. I dont know if its Nikki Haley. I dont think all of them would consider themselves conservatives, but many of them moved for that approach. An acquaintance of mine turned down an appointment as ambassador to Ireland early in the Trump administration, because while he and his wife were measuring drapes at the Phoenix Park ambassadors residence, they realized there was far too much anti-Trump flak and hatred coming from the press and RTE. Artificial Intelligence, Fifth Generation Warfare, Intermarium as a Viable Model for White Revival, My Father Left Me Ireland: An American Sons Search for Home, When this was first published a couple of years ago, reviewers had two distinct takes about the book. This book covers a lot of subjects: fatherhood and its absence; motherhood, unnoticed and undervalued; consumerism; the Catholic faith; poetry and politics; authenticity; revolution; the meaning of sacrifice. But I feel like it didnt used to be the way parties processed defeat. The parish was established in 1879 and in 2015 merged with nearby St. Elizabeth of Hungary and St. Stephen of Hungary churches. But also, she hadnt really given up on the Irishman, who by this point had left England to go back to Ireland. Thats a C-plus line, right? Who is Kevin McCarthy? Yeah, and I want to come back to that because that is, I think, a really interesting dynamic. Let the failures cascade so the dam may break. And Ron DeSantis, if hes going to make the big jump from a state to a national campaign, he has to speak to the whole countrys fate. Megyn Kelly is joined by Jim Geraghty and Michael Brendan Dougherty of National Review, to discuss Don Lemon's sexist comments about women and Nikki Haley being "past their prime," his pattern of misogynistic outbursts, Chris Cuomo saying he wanted to "kill everyone and himself" after he got fired, the network's downward spiral, President Biden's latest racially-insensitive comment, trans . I am indebted to him for the many sacrifices he made on my behalf, and the focused, intentional efforts he made to communicate to me masculinity, Christianity, and patriotism. And its like, oh, my gosh, if theres an unstoppable political message on my television, show it to me. And the proof is in the culture this ritual produces. There I learned that the Latin language was not the only distinguishing feature of this form of worship. There are a lot of Republicans and a bunch of them hold power, but thats kind of it. The other point of view was that it was more social critique than memoir, much as J. D. VancesHillbilly Elegy was. Bravo! (A full transcript of the episode is available here.). I despair for the most part- of the Irish tribe in our own time. Then you cant translate what people want into policy because the act of the compromise is more loathed than the possible benefits it could bring. Behan already had a wife in Ireland, and soon died anyway, age 41. I mean, theres a Republican autopsy in 2012, where they start thinking about needing to appeal more to multiethnic voters and change the nature of their coalition. And if so, why do you think it is? Her choice to keep and raise the young Michael garnered the type of superficial respect that is doled out by members of the bien pensant upper-middle class to suffering mothers. But I covered Covid and had a general sense. And yeah, he has that fantasy power of, hey, a businessman was in charge. Mar-a-Lago is like the closest thing America has ever had to a court of exile for a royal, right? Florida never expanded Medicaid. AEI's Timothy. In the simple majority, it fluctuates. In any case, a book about the virtues of nationalism is bound to raise thorny geopolitical questions. So that Im kind of hopeful for, that elected Republican legislators will have a little bit more to say about legislation, even if its not going to go anywhere in the next two years. And what exactly would a healthy and reasonable American nationalism look like, given that the United States is now in many ways more like an empire than a nation? And so hed be very hard for Democrats to compromise with. With the older generation, in particular my parents, coming from a childhood with no running water and sharing a bed as kids growing up, the material advances definitely resulted in an non sceptical approach to globalism. Valerie was a free spirit, like Michaels mum, and decided shed raise her bastard boy as an unmarried single mother. The Church of St. Monica, commonly referred to as St. Monica's, is a parish church in the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New York, located at 413 East 79th Street, Manhattan, New York City. Wed like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. He is the founder and editor of The Slurve, a newsletter about baseball. sonoma academy calendar; why are my bluetooth headphones connected but not working; michael brendan dougherty fordham; By . Those questions will need to be answered somehow over the next two years, as Republican politicians compete for their partys nomination for the 2024 presidential election and Republican House members wield the power of their new majority. I know the way out may be through. But it is questionable whether Republicans even understand the politics of this. Most importantly, he writes glowingly of Patrick Pearse, the Irish poet, teacher, and leader of the ill-fated 1916 revolt against the British. And I just dont see any other figure uniting the whole of the Republican Party and presenting opportunities for expansion the way I do in DeSantis. And when Californians leave, they go to Texas, not to, as often, Florida. And Trump also communicates in a way that feels can often feel authentic and more connected emotionally to an audience than his Republican rivals who are used to speaking with nerds like us, journalists and people that write policy white papers. And that makes sense because Joe Biden is President. Thats no longer the case. But that is what it is. This is what is going to happen to Republicans now in the Trump era is theyre going to become these doltish figures. He writes quite stirringly: Nationalism does not spring from the meatheaded conviction that ones nation is best in every way, but from something like a panicked realization that nobody in authority or around you is taking the nation seriously, that everyone is engaged in some private enterprise, while the common inheritance is being threatened or robbed. Such shallowness was hard to avoid during the 1990s. One was that it was a wistful, sometimes bittersweet memoir about growing up without a father, because the father was off in Ireland, having never married Doughertys American mother; and also, the author had some romantic notions about Ireland, andwasnt thatspecial. But Trump just works with these passions. So Ron DeSantis was a conventional conservative in Congress before he ran for governor who was sort of where the trend lines were in his party. My jokes fell flat because they had never heard of the Confederation, didnt know Confederation Day. Were never told, but it appears she was some kind of high-level administrative assistant. I mean, I like the polling. As always, my email, ezrakleinshow@nytimes.com. They aimed not only to adopt American culture, but to make it an inheritance for their children. And so I wanted to have a post-election conversation with someone deeper inside the Republican tent than I am about how the party is processing the last election, how it is preparing for the next one, what the factions are, what the structure is, and what a Kevin McCarthy speakership might look like in between. Democrats really fall in line. This is The Ezra Klein Show.. I want to totally abstract whether he was right to do that or wrong to do that. But that respect, Dougherty argues, comes with little in the way of material solidarity from either neighbors or employers. So I think thats another thing to look at. However, I got to say I am on the team put all your eggs in the DeSantis basket. And again, like you said, he disappeared from that answer, too. Freedom is won by the sacrifice of the few, and sustained in the kind of culture such sacrifices inspire. I mean, it used to be about the voters you needed to win back. I dont know how painful they are willing to make our religious life. And I think that calculated risk and the way he put himself out front, even more so than Brian Kemp in Georgia, made him a kind of conservative hero. monologue, that has become controversial for other reasons we dont need to go into, had this good point when he said that the thing that is appealing about Trump is that hes an honest liar. Yeah, hes going to have this. Johannes Vermeer's treatment of love distinguished him from his peers. But Dougherty is very much in control. And weve even seen a shift during the last four or five years. Counter-Currents has extended special privileges to those who donate $120 or more per year. Thats from in-migration. Yeah, and some of it is burned trust from before, which is its almost legendary in conservative circles that, oh, Ronald Reagan made a deal on immigration, which was amnesty now and were going to get enforcement at the border later. So he seemed more vulnerable than maybe a Greg Abbott. This ferment was accompanied by radical new theologies around the Mass. I was going to ask you about that leadership change because the Republican Party certainly looks and feels different to people, to me, than it did in 2004 or 2012. My father was himself of Polish descent, something most people who knew him were well aware of. Yet this Mass and the modestly growing contingent of Catholics who attend it are seen by Pope Francis as a grave problem. I assume it's someone I know. There was a big demand for that among people, and it showed in Florida tourism, both nationally and from internationally, that a lot of people wanted this, at least temporarily. I think being majority leader in such a slim majority, he doesnt have the institutional polar weight that Nancy Pelosi had in her party to keep things running smoothly. Granted, such a view may seem impracticable, as empire now seems to be the only alternative to nation, and empires (like Rome) swallow up nations before eventually breaking apart. I mean, the whole issue of inflation was its a global issue thats an after-effect of Covid. And I know many Democratic commentators and voters are like, this is a party that runs against debts and deficits when Democrats are in charge and then spends like crazy when theyre in charge to please their voters. And so hes seen as a potential viable successor or bridge from Trump to the future. They started calling Indians First Nations and giving them massive subsidies. View a list of book recommendations from our guests here. And they talk a lot about Bernie Sanders or Joe Biden or whomever. The study of literature no longer animates students' minds and souls. Mum and Dad met up at long intervals, most memorably when little Michael was five years old and they visited County Clare and the Aran Islands. Do not post your comment a second time. (Typically, Dougherty doesnt tell us where this was, but it seems to have been upstate New York.) We live in an age of disinheritance, with longings that we are discouraged from acknowledging, MBD writes. Michael, what are three books youd recommend to the audience? Please email comments to [emailprotected] and join the conversation on our Facebook page. Yet Dougherty is fundamentally American. You have this very strategic Democratic Party that emerges out of 2016. Original music by Isaac Jones. Doug Mastriano, the Republican candidate for governor in Pennsylvania, is not a billionaire real estate developer whos been on television for decades and Howard Sterns show for a decade. Anyway, pregnant Mum left London and went back home to Essex County, New Jersey, where baby Michael was born.